Help with Solids of Revolutions: volume of space between y=2x-x^2 and y=-2x+x^2

NicholasBlake

New member
Joined
May 29, 2018
Messages
2
Hi,
I need to find the volume of the space between these two equations. I have learned the "Washing Machine Method" but have been told that can't be used when one of the functions is negative. Any help would be appreciated

y=2x-x^2 and y=-2x+x^2

Thank you
 
Hi,
I need to find the volume of the space between these two equations. I have learned the "Washing Machine Method" but have been told that can't be used when one of the functions is negative. Any help would be appreciated

y=2x-x^2 and y=-2x+x^2

Thank you

You have not learned the "Washing Machine Method", at least I think not. Maybe someone calls it that. Usually, we have Shells, Disks, and Washers.

Assuming we are spinning around the x-axis, the problem with the function that is negative over the given Range isn't a problem at all. You have a choice:

1) Observe the symmetry and simply ignore the negative-valued function, or
2) Rotate around the axis only through \(\displaystyle \pi\) rather than \(\displaystyle 2\pi\).
3) Think about it long enough, simply proceed as you normally would, and divide by 2.

Can you show us how to proceed if you were simply to ignore y = -2x + x^2?

Note: In my opinion, ALL THREE methods "work" for EVERY such problem. In some cases, one or two might be particularly difficult. With some experience, you will begin to see which method is easiest for a particular problem.

Note: I have always made a habit of using both shells and disks (or washers) for EVERY practice problem. Lot's of experience and an opportunity to check your own work. :)
 
Last edited:
Hi,
I need to find the volume of the space between these two equations. I have learned the "Washing Machine Method" but have been told that can't be used when one of the functions is negative. Any help would be appreciated

y=2x-x^2 and y=-2x+x^2

Thank you
Can you please tell me what a negative function is as I am not familiar with that term at all.
 
Hi,
I need to find the volume of the space between these two equations. I have learned the "Washing Machine Method" but have been told that can't be used when one of the functions is negative. Any help would be appreciated

y=2x-x^2 and y=-2x+x^2

I don't see that you have stated what axis you are revolving around! Without that, we can't really give any specific help.

One thing I can do is to explain what the "washer method" refers to. It has nothing to do with "washers" in the sense of "washing machines", but with this kind of washer. It is a disk with a hole in it. It can be used whenever slices of a solid of revolution have that sort of shape.

Please tell us specifically where you need help.
 
Clarification

Sorry for any confusion. Here is a picture of the problem. I am new to the site so I am not sure if the image went up properly.

Image-1.jpg
 
Sorry for any confusion. Here is a picture of the problem. I am new to the site so I am not sure if the image went up properly.

View attachment 9579
My suggestion would be to

(1) draw "rough" sketches of the functions including the including the domain and range limit lines

(2) calculate the intersection points of the curves and the range and the domain lines. This determines the limits of integration.

Please tell us what you find.
 
Top